There is nothing more frustrating than gathering your squad for some 3v3 co-op action in MLB The Show 26, only to get slammed with random disconnections, infinite matchmaking searches, or sudden freezes right before the first pitch. If you and your friends are stuck staring at broken lobbies or constant network errors, you are definitely not alone.
The good news is that these 3v3 co-op bugs are usually caused by a few specific culprits: display refresh rate mismatches on modern consoles or temporary, bugged lobby data. By following this straightforward troubleshooting guide, you can resolve these hidden system conflicts and get your squad back onto the diamond without the headaches.
Fix 1: Disable 120Hz Mode (The Primary Console Fix)
Believe it or not, the 120Hz refresh rate mode in your console's display settings is the single most common trigger for sudden lobby crashes and matchmaking network errors when loading into a 3v3 online session. For whatever reason, the co-op netcode frequently clashes with high-refresh-rate outputs.
-
On PlayStation 5: Go to the console Settings menu, select Screen and Video, then choose Video Output. Locate the "Enable 120 Hz Output" option and switch it from Automatic to Off.
-
On Xbox Series X|S: Open the console Settings menu, navigate to General, and select TV & Display Options. Change the refresh rate drop-down from 120Hz down to 60Hz.
-
Restart the Game: Once you have adjusted your console's native display settings, completely restart the game application, launch MLB The Show 26 again, and try loading into a fresh 3v3 lobby.
Fix 2: Reset the Hosted Lobby Session
If your squad is hitting immediate disconnections or the game freezes up on the team selection screen right before a match begins, it usually means your current hosted session has become corrupted in the backend servers.
-
Hard Close the Game: Have all three players completely close out of the MLB The Show 26 application. Don't just idle in the menu; force-quit the app from your console dashboard.
-
Rotate the Host Role: Switch up who is hosting the party. As a rule of thumb, the player with the strongest, most stable wired Ethernet connection should be the one creating the new group.
-
Re-invite and Search: Have the new host send out fresh invites to the squad, group up, and start the matchmaking search.
Fix 3: Disable Crossplay (If Lobbies Fail to Fill)
If you find yourself stuck in matchmaking indefinitely, searching for opponents for minutes on end, or constantly getting slapped with a "Matchmaking Failed" pop-up, cross-platform communication might be stalling out on the server side.
-
Navigate to the MLB The Show 26 Main Menu and open your Profile icon located in the top left corner.
-
Go over to Options and look for the Crossplay setting.
-
Toggle Crossplay to Off.
Note: For this fix to work, all 3 players in your squad must be playing on the same console family (e.g., all on PlayStation or all on Xbox) and all 3 must have Crossplay turned off simultaneously.
Fix 4: Clear Console Cache & Check Server Status
Persistent network errors can also stem from corrupted local server handshake data stored on your system. A clean power cycle wipes away these temporary conflict files.
-
Power Cycle Your Console: Turn off your console completely. Do not put it into Rest or Standby mode. Unplug the main power cable from the back of the machine, wait a full 30 seconds to completely drain the cache, plug it back in, and power it up.
-
Check the Live Servers: If your entire squad is still blocked from playing after attempting all the steps above, the issue is likely on San Diego Studio's end. Keep an eye on the MLB The Show Downdetector page or check the official @MLBTheShow X (Twitter) account to see if the matchmaking servers are undergoing live maintenance or experiencing temporary outages.